top of page
Search

Balancing Neutrality and Engagement in Arbitration

phillip568

Serving as an arbitrator requires both impartiality and active participation to guide parties toward a fair resolution. Neutrality in arbitration means applying the same standards to each party, making determinations solely on evidence and legal principles rather than personal biases. When parties trust that the arbitrator is truly impartial, they are more likely to accept and abide by the ultimate decision.


Despite maintaining neutrality, an arbitrator must also remain engaged. This can involve asking pointed questions to clarify complex issues and ensuring both parties have adequately explained their positions. If an issue is unclear, pausing the proceedings to seek additional information or review pertinent evidence can significantly enhance the accuracy of the final outcome.


Striking the right balance between neutrality and engagement can be challenging. Excessive intervention may give the impression of siding with one party, while too little involvement risks overlooking critical details. The following best practices help maintain this delicate balance:

  1. Establish Clear Guidelines: At the outset, provide a detailed overview of the arbitration process. This clarifies roles, timelines, and the expectations for conduct, giving all parties a shared framework.

  2. Ask Equitable Questions: Formulate inquiries that allow both parties to expand on their arguments. Avoid phrasing that implies agreement or alignment with any single perspective.

  3. Foster a Respectful Environment: Should the dialogue become tense, remind participants of their shared goal—resolving the dispute. A respectful atmosphere enables clear thinking and constructive discourse.

  4. Explain Reasoning: After rendering the award, offer a concise explanation of how the evidence, legal standards, and arguments guided the decision. Transparency in the thought process promotes confidence in the outcome.



Ultimately, balancing neutrality with thoughtful engagement is an essential aspect of effective arbitration. By remaining impartial, actively clarifying critical points, and encouraging respectful participation, arbitrators can provide decisions that parties view as both equitable and well-founded.

Comments


bottom of page